Welcome to Executive Benefit Plans, Inc.

 

SIMPLE IRA vs. SIMPLE 401k

There Is A Difference!

 

Requirement

 

SIMPLE IRA

 

SIMPLE 401(k) PLAN

 

Eligible employers

 

100-employee rule (Section V, Part A)

 

Same

 

Document

 

Form 5305-SIMPLE or Form 5304-SIMPLE, prototype or individually-drafted (Section V, Part C)

 

Qualified plan document, Model amendment provided in Rev. Proc. 97-9

 

Eligible employees

 

$5,000 of compensation in 2 prior years, and expected to receive $5,000 in current year (Section V, Part D)

 

Qualified plan rules apply (e.g., 1 year/age 21) (Section VI, Part B)

 

Exclusive plan

 

Yes (Section V, Part B)

 

Same

 

Related employer rules

 

Apply

 

Same

 

Coverage testing

 

Not applicable

 

Applies (Section VI, Part B)

 

Elective contributions

 

Limited to $6,000 per calendar year; 60-day election period prior to beginning of year (but additional election periods permitted) (Section V, Part G)

 

Same

 

Matching contribution

 

Capped at 3% of compensation (may be reduced down to 1% cap in 2 of 5 years) (Section V, Part G)

 

Capped at 3%  (no reduction on cap allowed) (Section VI)

 

Nonelective contributions

 

2% of compensation (Section V, Part G)

 

Same

 

Nondiscrimination tests

 

Not applicable (Section V, Part H)

 

Same

 

Vesting

 

All contributions 100% vested (Section V, Part G)

 

Same

 

Top heavy rules

 

Not applicable (Section V, Part H)

 

Same

 

Section 415 limits

 

Not applicable (Section V, Part F)

 

Applicable (Section VI, Part B)

 

Compensation dollar limit

 

Only applies to nonelective contributions (Section V, Part G)

 

Applies to matching and nonelective contributions (Section VI, Part B)

 

Section 402(g) limit

 

Applies (Section V, Part G)

 

Same

 

Employer deduction

 

No 15% deduction limit (Section V, Part G)

 

Same (Section VI, Part B)

 

Form 5500 filing

 

No (Section V, Part H)

 

Yes (Section VI, Part B)

 

Trust accounting

 

Not applicable (Section V, Part H)

 

Required (Section VI, Part B)

 

Transmittal of elective contributions

 

Earlier of: 1) 30 days after close of month. or 2) earliest date employer able to segregate from its assets (Section V, Part F)

 

Earlier of: 1) 15th business day of the following month, or 2) earliest date able to segregate

 

Fiduciary responsibility

 

Limited, expires after no more than 1 year (Section V, Part F)

 

Normal ERISA rules apply

 

Withdrawals

 

Permitted anytime; 25% tax penalty applies if employee is under age 59-1/2 and withdrawal is in first 2 years (Section V, Part I)

 

Terms of plan control; selection 401(k) restrictions apply (Section VI, Part D); no 25% penalty

 

Minimum distributions

 

Must start by April 1 of year following calendar year in which age 70-1/2 attained (Section VI, Part B)

 

Must start by April 1 of year following later of: 1) calendar year age 70-1/2, or 2) calendar year retires, if employee is not 5% owner (Section VI, Part B). For a 5% owner, the rule is the same as for SIMPLE-IRAs

 

Rollovers

 

Only into another SIMPLE-IRA or other IRA (Section V, Part I)

 

Into qualified plan or IRA (other than SIMPLE-IRA) (Section VI, Part B)

 

Joint and survivor rules

 

Not applicable

 

Required unless exemption requirements under IRC §401(a)(11) are satisfied (Section VI, Part B)

 

Plan year

 

Must be calendar year (Section V, Part C)

 

Same

 

Participant loans

 

Not permitted

 

Permitted

Privacy Statement - Executive Benefit Plans, Inc. Copyright 1996 - 2008 All Rights Reserved - Legal Statement
Website Powered by UHSystems